• Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer
Show Search
Hide Search
Clare Kumar | Inclusive & Sustainable Performance
1-855-356-FLOW (3569) | Contact
  • Speaking
    • Speaker Kit
  • Coaching
  • Products
    • Books
    • Cool Tools
    • InclusiviTee™️
    • Pliio®️
  • Programs
    • Total Team Work
    • Thrive Sessions
    • Work From Home – Better
    • Productivity CPR: Rituals
  • Happy Space
    • Work Style Profile
    • Thrive Circles
    • Hot Topics
    • Podcast
    • HSP Quiz
  • Blog
  • Media
    • Media Kit
  • About
    • Client Praise
ep57_cover_art_400

Episode 57 - What To Say So They Can’t Unhear - with Tamsen Webster

Message Master, Tamsen Webster shares powerful ways to communicate and say what they can’t unhear.

Share:

Share on Facebook
𝕏 Share on X
Share on Linkedin

Messager Master, Tamsen Webster discusses the pivotal role of effective messaging in achieving transformational change. She explores the dichotomy of messaging from recent political conventions, and the importance of framing messages positively. Tamsen delves into the science behind persuasion, the necessity of aligning with shared values, and the broader implications of these principles in both personal and professional spheres. The conversation emphasizes the potential of strategic communication to foster meaningful and sustainable change, urging listeners to adopt a more thoughtful and empathetic approach to messaging.

BIO

Part message designer, part English-to-English translator, part magpie, Tamsen Webster helps leaders craft their case for large-scale change. A sought-after speaker and consultant, she’s spent more than 25 years developing the field and practice of persuasive message design, with a particular focus on the principles and processes that build buy-in that lasts.

In addition to her work in and for major organizations such as Harvard Medical School, Fidelity Investments, and Klaviyo, she built and delivers the message design curriculum for Elemental Excelerator, a leading investor in impact startups. She’s a judge and mentor for the Harvard Innovation Labs and a professional advisor at the Martin Trust Center for MIT Entrepreneurship. She’s also spent over 10 years as the Idea Strategist for one of only nine legacy-level TEDx events and was named to the Thinkers50 Radar in 2022. She published her first book, Find Your Red Thread: Make Your Big Ideas Irresistible, in 2021. Her next book, Say What They Can't Unhear: The 9 Principles of Lasting Change is available in bookstores everywhere in October 2024.

Tamsen was a reluctant marathoner… twice; is a champion ballroom dancer (in her mind); and learned everything she knows about messages, people, and change as a Weight Watchers leader. True story.

She lives in Boston with her husband, two sons, and her two brindle Greyhounds, Hazel and Walnut.

 

CHAPTERS

09:04 How to use Tamsen's book and possible resistance to it.

14:00 Have we lost optimism bias?

20:34 It's about change communications

27:00 Mindset and ego

33:45 Finding common ground

39:42 Primal beliefs and squandering human potential

47:39 Stories in messaging

53:02 People are not willing to go back into the machine

56:16 Benefits of adult learning

 

LINKS

Jer Clifton - Primal World Beliefs

Tamsen Webster’s Website

The Ladder of Inference - Chris Argyris and Donald Schoen

Find Your Red Thread by Tamsen Webster

Say What They Can’t Unhear - by Tamsen Webster

Harvard Innovation Labs

The Martin Trust Centre for MIT Entrepreneurship

 

IMAGE CREDITS (see images on Youtube video)

Book graphics - Amazon.ca

Other Images and Graphics - Canva

Harvard Innovation Labs logo - Harvard Innovation Labs

MIT Centre logo  - MIT Centre

Jer Clifton - Linkedin

Tamsen Webster headshot - Tamsen Webster

 

Learn more about and follow Tamsen:

Instagram

Youtube

Twitter

LinkedIn

Website

😀😃😄😁😆

Highly sensitive executive coach and productivity catalyst, Clare Kumar, explores the intersection of productivity and inclusivity exploring how we can invite the richest contribution from all through improvements in design and culture. She works bottom-up - coaching individuals in sidestepping burnout and cultivating sustainable performance, and top-down – working with leaders to design inclusive performance thereby inviting teams to reach their full potential. As a speaker, Clare mic-drops “thought balms” in keynotes and workshops, whether virtual or in-person. She invites connection through her online community committed to designing sustainable and inclusive performance, the Happy Space Pod. Why? Because everyone deserves a Happy Space.

Believing that productivity is personal, the podcast is produced in a variety of formats so you can enjoy it in the medium you prefer:

Listen to the audio right here or on your fave podcast platform.

If you prefer to watch video, check out the episode on YouTube. And look for the Shorts playlist for clips.

If you prefer to read, please see the transcript below.

Ready to learn more, or want to find out more about coaching with Clare or hiring her for your next engaging event? Contact Clare here.

😀😃😄😁😆

If you enjoyed this episode, please leave a heartfelt review as this will help other listeners discover the podcast.  Please invite your colleagues, friends, and family to listen as well. Together we can design a more inclusive world where everyone can make their richest contribution.

Want to learn more about Clare and/or her guests?  Follow Clare on Instagram and Twitter.

And don't forget, everyone (including YOU) deserves a Happy Space. 😊

 

CREDITS

Audio and Video Editing: Jaclyn Enchin

Production Assistant: Rafael Dona

Song Credit: Cali by Wataboi  / wataboi

Creative Commons — Attribution 3.0 Unported — CC BY-SA 3.0Music promoted by FDL Music  • Cali - Wataboi · [Copyright-free Music]

EPISODE TRANSCRIPT

Clare Kumar: You're listening to episode 57 of the Happy Space Podcast. Today, we're exploring powerful ways to get your message across by saying what they can't unhear with message designer, Tamsen Webster.

Clare Kumar: ​​Hot on the heels of the Democratic National Convention, I'm seeing comments today in a variety of social media platforms about culling friends lists because of misaligned values.  This is the absolute opposite of persuasion. With the 2024 U.S. election still in front of us at the time of recording and approaching very quickly as we release this episode, it was really natural to start to look at today's topic in the context of politics. 

Today, I'm speaking with Tamsen Webster, author of Finding Your Red Thread, Make Your Ideas Irresistible, a book and methodology I repeatedly refer to whenever I'm forming my own persuasive messages,  and now her second book, Say What You Can't Unhear. The nine principles of lasting change, which makes messages not only more compelling, but change more likely to endure.

Tamsen works with organizations who want to be effective and efficient in getting their messages across, not only to be understood, but also to be agreed with. Tamsen came to her curiosity about change communication through her own transformational journey and helping others as a Weight Watchers leader.

She spent over 10 years as the idea strategist for a legacy level TEDx event and was named in 2022 to the Thinker's 50 Radar. And this is a group of people I'm privileged to know many. You'll actually see a few on the podcast, Heather Hansen and yudmila Praslova as well. It's a group of people who are esteemed for their ability to think about new things in new ways. 

Tamsen is a judge and mentor for the Harvard Innovation Labs and a professional advisor at the Martin Trust Center for MIT Entrepreneurship.  If you want to convince someone to change the way they are thinking and acting, this is for you. Listen to find out why to be most effective you need to keep your ego in check,  how flipping the risk increases your odds of success, and what to do if someone seems to have wildly different beliefs than you. 

If you want to change what's around you, this is not a time to give up. This is a time to learn how to say what they can't unhear. 

 

Clare Kumar: Tamsen Webster thrilled to have you with me and for our listeners to get to hear from you directly. 

Tamsen Webster: I'm delighted and such color and joy coming from you, Clare. This is gonna be fun. 

Clare Kumar: Yeah, I mean, we had a lovely conversation. I was just mentioning to you before I hit record now that we could have recorded that it was so good.

And so any time I get to spend with you, I'm always learning and come away with new insights. So this is going to be a gift listeners. And let's get right into it because we're, if you're listening, when this podcast is going to be released, it's a particularly interesting time in the US in particular, because there's a big election happening and your body of work.

As a message master message designer is all around effectively getting your point across being persuasive and boy, that's the name of the game right now. Yeah. And I kind of want to open talking about, you know, why did that have anything to do with, Your choice of timing around when, when the book was released and sort of supporting what's going on now, or is, I mean, it's an absolutely nothing.

Tamsen Webster: Yeah, it, it was, it's, it ends up being delightful timing, but it was a rich, the book was originally supposed to come out in May and I just missed a few deadlines. And then eventually it was like, I, this was as early as they could my publisher's page two could could put it out, , given the fact that we were putting it.

We wanted to put it into physical bookstores and all of that. It just happened to be, , that this is the right time for it. It feels like the right time. But nobody could have predicted the, turn around, I think, in energy and optimism and tone and timbre, since you’re a singer of the campaign.

Right. That happened when, Kamala Harris took over the nomination from Joe Biden. And I'm very excited about that because it seems to be politics, truly politics aside, just the kind of forward looking narrative building that is generally the kind of thing that I'd love to, that I, that I know and have observed as works, but I also personally love to stand for.

Clare Kumar: Love it. So fortuitous things, things shall happen when they may, you know, at the right time, a little bit of exactly. Yeah. But you know what I think about this and I think about the politicians and I want to get to that, but I'm thinking about individuals and the message you have for every individual because what I'm taking away from this is, and I watched a fair bit of the Democratic National Convention, even though I'm in Toronto, I just, I found it, I found it kind of interesting looking at the messaging coming out of that versus a little bit of what was coming out of the Republican National Convention.

And to me, it really struck a chord. There's, the DNC was really about fighting for freedom, looking for justice, social activism, and a real strong message of hope. Yeah. Whereas the Republican National Convention was really derogatory talking about the challenges we're facing. It left you feeling deflated and playing up fear rather than playing up love and compassion.

I see that dichotomy very strongly. What I saw today in my social media posts on a couple of platforms was, well, if I saw your reaction, for example, and you might not have seen this, this was a really powerful moment with Gus Walz. Oh, I did see that. I did you see 

Tamsen Webster: Oh, marvelous. 

Clare Kumar: Yeah. I thought it was one of the most beautiful things I've ever seen on television.

And I wake up this morning to, you know, or yesterday to messages about you know, attacking someone who's neurodivergent, as am I, different capabilities of expression. There was such unbridled joy and love in what he displayed there. I woke up to comments today with people saying, I've seen your values.

I'm unfriending you, boom, boom, boom, shut down. This happened in the pandemic too. There was a lot of sort of polarization. I think your body of work is for everyone, specifically, yes, for the people that are crafting messages and really getting it out, but everybody has the opportunity here to craft a message and be in conversation.

So yeah, what do you, what do you say when you're thinking of how you want this book to be used and the invitation to the person who's just like, I'd rather unfriend you than be in conversation? 

Tamsen Webster: Well, that's, well, the first thing is if somebody is not looking, if somebody is not. If there's not something that somebody is trying to find an answer for, then, then they're not going to be open to this book.

And that's one of the first and most important things I think that, that any person can engage with. It aligns with my eighth principle that you can't want it more than they do, meaning I know that there are places you could use this, that, that. Opportunities for change, they could change, you know, I see it as changing anything from, from individual lives all the way through business and societal and social movements.

I can't sell it that way because someone's going to be, there's no way one thing does all those things. I get that. But the second thing is, is that if you're not looking for that kind of forward moving change, this is. It's then it's not going to align with what you're looking for. So I think that, , you know, what I observe is when you were talking about the tone of the two different narratives that you, you had observed, you know, it, this idea of anchoring on fear and pain is regardless of where it is.

And I focused more in the book on, on doing that for sales and marketing purposes than on political, but again, we can see it at any nber of places. Okay. It just doesn't work long term. I mean, and so, and there's something more specific that I had an insight about the other day, and that is, you know, the, an anxious brain, a fearful brain, a brain that is in pain, literally cannot think rationally.

Yeah. And that's not an opinion, right? Like that's, that is supported, well researched, evidence backed science, is that an anxious brain can't listen, can't process, can't learn. So whenever people dial up pain to get a message across or as part of their message, not As a mode of let me identify with you and observe and empathize with what the struggle that you're going through, but rather when they use it to amplify and try to urge action because they're trying to drive that action based on that pain or that fear.

I sit back and say, you are talking, you are creating a situation in which someone cannot be open to something and which they are then therefore motivated to just do something, but something not rational. And I got to stop back and say, well, why, why are you doing that? I mean, it really, anytime I see someone anchoring on pain, again, in any situation, sometimes they do it knowingly, sometimes they don't, but you have to ask yourself who benefits from that because it's usually not the person.

That they're talking to.

Clare Kumar: It just struck me that maybe this is thought through maybe Trump gets that because maybe he just wants people to stay and do take no action. Don't get curious. Don't explore just stick with me and I’m gonna keep with whatever makes you 

Tamsen Webster: Feel safe, right? And that's that's what you're motivated to do when you are anxious is it restricts the options that you're open to.

So it doesn't mean that you won't act when you're, yeah, when you're experiencing that, but it means that you're going to act for preservation. You're going to act for self preservation. And so what I find is that, so there, that's happening, but there's also very good research and, and evidence that shows that when we frame potential changes through a problem based lens, and now think about how often not only do we do that, but we are told to do that, to encourage to do that.

Startups are saying, well, what, what's the real problem that you solve? What's the problem you solve? What's the problem you solve? What's the problem you solve? There is research that shows that you, from linguistics and a learning perspective, that when you frame thing, something through a problem, it immediately, closes the options that your brain is willing to consider, not just because of any fear that you could, this could happen outside of activating a fear mindset,

If you're just trying to solve the problem, then all your focus is on solved, not solved, fixed, not fixed. There's this, this. Duality. But when you talk about what is on the other side of the challenge, not necessarily a big broad brushstrokes of, of what, of goals, but instead of saying like, you're going to lose this thing.

And you say, how can we gain this opportunity? How can we maintain our market advantage? How can we achieve this thing? Right. , A lot of times there is something in the way to get you there. But what happens, what they see in the research is that it immediately expands someone's ability to, to consider other options.

Not to mention the fact that we do, as hans, have an optimism bias, , so, which is, I think, one of the reasons why this, this joyful, forward looking tongue, finally, is one that is capturing so much energy and attention right now. 

Clare Kumar: I, I feel like we've lost this optimism bias. Is it there in everyone, or is this in particular temperaments?

I feel like we've lost it a little bit. 

Tamsen Webster: Well, we can lose it if we are put, if we are, if, if we are put into or find ourselves or put ourselves into that anxious brain moment all the time, 

Clare Kumar: Right? But the thing is, the pandemic, for example, anxious brain, absolutely. We were there for a long 

Tamsen Webster: And so that's the thing. Like when, when you're anxious, it's not possible to see a broader picture. And so that's part of what, you know, you said like, who is this for? And I'm like, yeah, I show me a day where you get through the day without having to persuade someone or some being to do something different than what they're doing right now, where you have to, you know, whether that's the, the child or the cat or the partner or, you know, business person, you know, the, the cable renewal guy. We have to do it all the time and we're not a taught how to do it, which is cuckoo bananas to me. , cause it is such a core life and business skill, our ability to effect change, right? Like our ability to just say, Hey, I need a thing to be different.

How do I do that? And how do I do that in a way that, that preserves relationships that, that, great. You know, whatever change that you're making is one that is sustainable or the one that you're asking someone to make is sustainable over time. 

Tamsen Webster: And that's part of where the, the, the pain and the fear angle run into trouble because And I think we're experiencing that.

We, we, we run into anxiety, fatigue. You get just, just get tired of feeling that way. And you don't want to keep doing anything that keeps you feeling that way. And so that's why we tend to, you know, stop doing hyper restrictive diets or hyper aggressive fitness programs. But I would suspect the same thing is true when you have kind of a whole narrative out there, whether that's in business or in politics, that's essentially the equivalent of the Debbie Downer character from SNL. Like you, we all have those friends. You don't want to spend a huge amount of time with them when they're like, it's, this is all, you know, like you, you say something positive and they're like, yeah, but, and you're like, Oh yeah.

Clare Kumar: The big buzz kill. Yeah. You're like, yeah, well it gets nber six, right? Pain is the enemy of long term change. And yes. And I thought, yeah, we can get caught up in short term impact, but that long term erosion of our need for joy and comfort is, is ultimately going to be our downfall. If, so we have to find, we have to find and fall in love with ways of being and acting.

Yes. That actually are deeply in line with who are, who we are. 

Tamsen Webster: That's right. We, because we won't do anything else over time. And I, I fully admit that I have a bias towards efficiency because it, and I, and I, I swear this is true. Like, I just think that at heart, I'm, I don't know that if, if I, it's just that I'm lazy or that I just want to get like, you know, be able to work on other things.

I'm impatient, and I know that I'm impatient, which means that I don't like to have to do anything twice. 

Clare Kumar: Oh, I feel you. I tell most of the people I work with that I was really terrible at practicing piano. Terrible. Like, give me a new thing to kind of learn, but don't make me, no I, yeah, I physically start to just switch.

Tamsen Webster: I'll, yeah. I hear you. And so, I mean, as someone who chose something, you know, chose communications, branding, marketing, message design, , as my career, that, and particularly, I spent most of my time working in or for resource constrained organizations, then, you know, you literally can't afford to for just for something not to work more for something not to work long term.

You need to be able to say a message and it be something that people can't unhear that that it just sticks with them and then it just changes their perspective. You, you need to be able to connect with someone quickly. And in a way that's, that is in a, as you said, in alignment with your ways of being and what, what you value, because it has to be in alignment with them too, because that's the only way we will sustain something long term.

And so it's just been a lifelong, truly a lifelong, passion. Like it's the only thing that I've been willing, you know, I don't consider that doing it twice because I keep trying to just unpack and solve for pieces and parts of this puzzle of what is it we can do to accelerate the adoption, the understanding first and adoption of new ideas, you know, and that's evolved over time is into how can I help people help other people make transformational change.

And yeah, so really what this book is, it's just, this is, this is, I mean, it's my manifesto in a lot of ways. I'd say manifesto, of just what I, of what I know works and what I have not seen all assembled in one place, all together, anywhere, as it's just a very, very different approach to, I mean, you have to call it persuasion, but anybody who reads the book understands that by the end of it, it's not actually about persuasion at all.

Clare Kumar: What do you call it? What do you say it's about then? If it's not about per…

Tamsen Webster: I think it's about communications that, you know, communicating change. It's change communications, but I, I, because it's, I mean, I will call it persuasion because that's what most people would recognize it as, but I think with most persuasion we are there is this, it implies for a lot of people, a much more active process of changing people's beliefs in, you know, in order to change their actions.

And we hear a lot of that. Well, you know, whether it's in psychology or other places, well, we've got to get rid of limiting beliefs. Well, yes. And when they are irrational, we absolutely do. But the thing is that a lot of times these, you know, in business or in other places of life, these limiting beliefs are limiting our perspective about what that person could or should be doing.

They're limiting to our change. What? But they are, they're not irrational, right? Those, those beliefs. And I think that's the real, that's the real challenge. , because. You know, a question I get a lot about this is, well, why are people so resistant to change? And it's saying, well, you know, it's, it's, they're, they're, they're not resistant to all change.

There's not a day that goes by that goes the way as planned. There's no such thing as a normal day. Every day has something that is different than what you expected or what you were planning before. So we're actually really good at it. , but what we are resistant to are certain kinds of change. We're resistant to changes that we anticipate as being very difficult or very painful.

We're resistant to, you know, to, you know, and then that gets us into what, what makes them difficult and painful. But you know, as others before me have pointed out, fundamentally, a lot of times that resistance comes from a fear of loss, right? Because we perceive a risk and the person that is asking us to change, sometimes that's ourselves, hasn't yet done the work of abating that risk for us.

, and in essence, a lot of times what we end up doing is just saying, trust me, you'll be fine. And for a lot of us, that is not okay, right? Like the people with the person that we trust the most is ourselves. So really what this process that I have seen work over and over again, and it's what's, you know, the principles are what are captured in the book is that.

This is about actually essentially stating your case and letting somebody else respond to that in such a way that if it is something that is aligned with how they see the world and how they want to be seen and with what it is that they want to achieve, then it will create the conditions in which they persuade themselves.

I forget at the moment who said all persuasion is self persuasion. But really that's what it is. It's but when you're when you know the book is written for leaders when you're in the position of helping or creating the conditions for somebody else to change. It really is understanding that that at least my belief is, is that the person who should asse that risk is the person you're, the person asking for the change, not the person who's, who's, you know, whose change you are asking for.

And that's really a lot of what's represented by this, this book as well as flipping, it's flipping where the risk is. Flip the risk. Yeah, the risk. Yeah. I mean, if you believe enough in the change, you, in my mind, the way I see it is if I believe enough in a change, if I believe enough in doing something a certain way to achieve a certain outcome, like I do with this book, like then I, I, I believe that I must be willing to state my case, to put that position out there, be willing to defend it, be ready to defend it, but also have confidence that, that I have done the work to, to make it as clear as understandable and as agreeable for the people who, with whom it would ever be.

understandable and agreeable. And the agreeable is the key part. , because if somebody isn't interested in, in, in long term change, this is not the book for them. You know, if they're not interested in, , you know, if they're not troubled by what others might consider manipulative, coercive, or, you know, externally, you know, threats and operant conditioning types of again, this is not the book.

There's plenty of other things out there that talk about that. But if that hasn't worked for folks, if that doesn't feel good, then I really wanted to put something out there that said, yes, there's another way. No, it's not just sparkle dust and pixies, right? It is haircut aside. But it is, but it is research based, evidence backed and in so many other fields than in business.

And, you know, and as you pointed out, it isn't just business that this book is about, but, you know, publishers are like, it has to be for, I know. But as I say in the book, most of these principles found their, at least their, their, the seed of where they started in my own personal transformational change and the work I did in creating and helping to create the conditions for others to make their own personal transformational change and then taking those lessons and then bringing them from the personal sphere into the professional, into the business world. And seeing that they, those principles just fundamentally worked better. I didn't see the levels of buyer's remorse. I saw a quicker alignment when I was in, when I used it in, in context of fundraising and things like that. We, we were able to raise bigger gifts. We were able to get more people involved, because we are just speaking Almost speaking a different language of quote unquote persuasion.

We're speaking their language. We're building the stories they can tell themselves about whatever this is. 

Clare Kumar: It, it is really powerful. And I remember when we first spoke, , a point that really stuck out to me was the place of ego in this. If we're going to start to de risk it for the other and take on the risk.

Can you talk a little bit about the mindset of the person trying to make the change and how you get to thinking that way? 

Tamsen Webster: Yeah. I mean, I think, I think there's probably different paths to thinking that way. I can really only speak to it, to my path about that. And that is, I've gotten to a point in my life, I don't think I was always here, where in a lot of cases the idea is more important.

Like whatever it is that I'm trying to serve is in fact more important. Like I am willing to, excuse the military analogies here, but I'm willing to lose a battle here and there in order to win the war. I'm willing to kind of sit back, wait, regroup, come back at it a different way, in order to really give everything that I've got for the purpose of, you know, putting something out there, helping a change happen, you know, trying again.

So, and on a grand scale, you know, that can be, you know, here's a big idea, but it can also happen just even if I'm engaging with clients, like there are certain times when the first way introduced something doesn't make any sense. Okay, well, I've got like, over time, I've developed like five other ways to explain the same thing, but I've even seen it with my own approaches, right?

So with my first book, Find Your Red Thread, it is presented as a very linear structure, and I found out very quickly from using it with some of my very good friends who are beautiful creatives, that a linear structure just doesn't work as well for them. They just, that's not how they think. They think kind of here and there and everything.

And gosh, I don't remember who said this recently, but it was the, the thinking doesn't have to be linear as long as the you know, what you hang it on eventually is, right? And so being able to even kind of recognize that and being able to, in that moment, say, well, I believe in the power of articulating information to other people in the structure of a story, but I'm, if I really want to help this person get their idea out there and my linear explanation of this process isn't working, then I say, well, then it's, I need to be willing to like, put myself, my process on the line and say, well, can we get to the same outcome?

If we approach it as they think about it, not, you know, this step, then this step, then this step. And. You know, the good news was that by, you know, after, you know, and of course there was some friction points where I was like, that doesn't work as well this way. Okay. I need to adjust it to make that work.

But to me, that's it. If you believe enough in something or you want whatever it is that you're building enough, then I, I literally can't see any other way to, to be about that. Because That's just, I know that's how I'm wired, so I wish I could give an answer if somebody's like, yeah, but I'm the most important thing, and I'm like, but I don't know, , so maybe this isn't, maybe this isn't the approach, maybe this is not the approach for them, , and that's, again, that's okay too, , because I just, you know, I just got to the point where it's like, you know, I've spent enough time now doing this that if I can't put myself at the center of somebody else's change.

I mean, I would, I mean, just even if you think about it as a, as a physical thing, I would literally be in their way. So yeah, exactly. So yeah, there has to, I have to give them distance, which means the thing that exists in between is the idea, the change, the, you know, whatever I can put in there and I can be encouraging.

I can make my case for it. I can do everything I can do. I can turn the phrases so that they are, you know, as impossible to unhear as I can get them. , And once I feel like I've gotten it as strong as it can be, that's all I can do, right? I mean, it is why I put this book through so many peer reviewers.

My publishers were like, what are you doing? And I'm like, I just really want to know, like, I want to know, like every spot where someone's like, I don't know about that. And I'm like, okay. Yeah. I mean, I think that it's, 

Clare Kumar: if someone isn't there yet. Yeah. Patience. That speaks to me of a patience and anchoring in curiosity and holding onto that to be able to work through the discomfort of thinking, I've got it.

The relief that comes with, I've got it to be like, there's more work to do. Like there's an appetite there. 

Tamsen Webster: Well, yeah. So I would say that I think patients, if somebody is patient, that's a thing to, to, to rest on with that. Like be patient, know that you will get there eventually. I am not patient. I am probably persistent to a fault.

I am just, you know, I am, there's, you know, there's another word that I can't come up with at the moment. Relentless. No, but it's just, it's, I am, I'm dogged in my pursuit of something until I am sure that it It will or won't work, right? And for a very long time, you know, as soon as I ever learned about confirmation bias, where we are more inclined to seek out the things that we believe to be true, I have adopted as my mantra, disconfirm what you believe to be true.

So I take anything that I think has that glimmer of that seems, and I'm just and I first I'm the first one to start trying to poke holes in it. And when I think I filled the holes, I will still turn it over to other people and say, find the holes. Because I am 100 percent sure that I cannot find them all.

There's just no way I don't have the I don't have the I don't have the no one person can incorporate the entire expanse of the way we think, the way that we see the world, the things that are important to us. And I'm not trying to capture everybody, but I want to make sure that there's nothing getting in the way of the people for whom this is most closely aligned.

Meaning, if you, you know, this, if you want to really get. Truly, folks, you know, emotionally to feel like a change is theirs, that they want it in and of themselves, not because anything is anything other than the outcome is conditional on it. It's not, they're not doing it because your approval is conditional on it.

They're not doing it because, you know, they'll have this, you know, this negative outcome if they don't. just because they're doing it for their own reasons, then if you want that, right? And if you, if you agree with the second principle is that, you know, the product of, you know, to get to that, we have to be able to tell ourselves a very convincing story about why this thing makes sense.

And this continued effort, whatever it might be, makes sense. And that we won't do anything over time if we cannot continue to tell ourselves a story that we agree with. And if you don't believe that, again, that book's not going to work for you. And then the last one is just, again, which I know is so, for some folks, so camera intuitive, but it sounds like once I, once I kind of looked at it, I was like, but wait a minute, if I'm trying to get somebody to agree to something, the easiest place to start is something that they've already agreed with.

So how, like how can I craft a case for change based on principles, beliefs, values that say that you and I both agree with? 

Tamsen Webster: And that means that I do have to be willing to do that work to drop out of identity based politics about like, oh, you're this kind of person, I'm that kind of person. 

And keep driving until we both. until I can find something where we both agree that that is either the way the world is or the way it should be. And if we get to that point and we can find common ground, that's really pretty exciting. For instance, in the, the doctoral program, I just started this smer.

It's a huge, I'm, which is so much fun. And I'm insane. One of my better friends so far, actually my two best friends in the program so far are both, well, one is, you know, are essentially retired army Rangers, like US army Rangers, like battle tested multiple trips to, you know, multiple, I'm going to get the word.

Yeah, exactly. Deployments. I mean, and these are Rangers, right? They're not just. One of them is this giant guy. He's libertarian and, you know, all this other stuff. And it was funny because we, but for whatever reason we were able, you know, we've been able to connect on these other levels. And, you know, I, it's just the, when we do that, there's always a moment where I'll just like, gosh, you're just not remotely like what I thought you would be.

Cause he looked at me and he was like, here's this little New England, clearly lives in Bostonian must be like super liberal person. She's going to like think X, Y, and Z about me for being in the army. And honestly, there is so much more that we have in common about the way to treat people and the way to have, you know, and the way to think about things and whatever, then we, then is different 

I am so grateful for the additional perspectives that somebody who is so different for me can, can, can provide. Again, that's not for everybody either, but you know, when, as we said, I come in from this perspective of, well, disconfirm what I believe to be true, I firmly believe that the more perspectives we can take, the better we can see something.

And, again, I can't see everything because I'm, you know, I am in the position that I am. Like I am a product of my own habits. I'm a product of, you know, my city, my country, my family. I'm a product of culture. I'm a product of my race. I'm a product of all these other things. And it's my job, to the extent that I can, to be as aware of them as I can be, and to be open when one that I was previously not aware of suddenly becomes.

Visible to me. 

Clare Kumar: Yeah. Yeah. So many things that you've talked about resonate with me. The fact that productivity is personal and we think differently. You said you had talked about being persistent and dogged. And I relate to that. I've often described myself as a Jack Russell terrier.

That's just like jping up really like high things and like, well, but you're not going to tell them don't want that. Anymore. They're just going to eat. Right. So I loved, I love that. I want to talk just a little bit about when you think, when you think someone's not going, are they going to care about this at all?

So when I'm working with organizations, I put up the point of view that we should stop unintentionally squandering han potential and that we should inherently value han contribution. That may not be a belief held. By the organizations or a CEO or somebody that, you know, they might be like humans commodities.

Totally. Absolutely. Don't mind grinding through and burnout the thing, deal with it yourself. Not my responsibility. Do I, do I just know that that's going to be the case? Or do I Jack Russell Terrier or that thing? And, you know, we're at what point is it that the primal beliefs, Yeah. Are so just opposed that the conversation is not going to go anywhere.

Tamsen Webster: Well, I'm glad you brought up the primal beliefs because they're, I continue to think that research, such as, Jerry Clifton and his team out of the university of Pennsylvania is some of the most important research for understanding hans, , and particularly persuasion, influence, change, change communications, interaction, period.

Because you know what they are, what they appear to be finding is that we have 26 pairs of primal world beliefs about just, you know, whether the world is good or bad, or whether it's safe or dangerous, or whether it's inherently hierarchical or not. And I think that's so important to know, probably for a reason that might surprise people, because I think you could look at that and go, then there's just some things that we can't resolve.

And I would say if you argue for them at that level, correct, right? If, yes, if you believe the world is a dangerous place and I believe it's a safe one and that is one of the primary, you know, premises of an agent for a change, I am not going to convince you because it is not a sound agent for you because you don't share that belief.

And, okay, so you may believe the world is dangerous, and I believe the world is safe, but I'm gonna bet that we both believe that germs contribute to disease. Or that what goes up must come down, or that the more perspectives you can take, the better you can see. Those are not primals they're pretty core.

And so this is one of the things I'm, I'm exploring in my, in my doctoral research is, outside of philosophy, has anyone really looked at these levels of beliefs? And even within philosophy, has anyone looked at these levels of belief? Because I'm fascinated by them. And, you know, , that's what I'm really interested in because, you know, a lot of the focus, particularly on business communication and those kinds of things, have been heavily influenced and rightly so, by the work of Argeris and Schoen and what's known as the Ladder of Inference, right?

So, I worked for a company that beautifully simplified it to, as no belief do, that based on what you, you know, observe and the information you take in, you develop beliefs, which affect what you, except the primal beliefs actually upset that perspective in my view, because the primal beliefs are not a product of what you know.

They're actually the ground on which that ladder sits underneath, right? So that it actually, those primal beliefs start as a filter like as a meta filter for even what information you pay attention to or how you, you interpret the information you take in in the first place. 

Clare Kumar: Yeah. 

Tamsen Webster: So I think those somewhere between the beliefs that are the product of.

You know, what you know from an identity standpoint or been socialized to or whatever, and these primal beliefs where there is a, it's not totally a reconcilable split. I have talked to Jared, to Dr. Clifton about this, and he says it is possible to change primal beliefs, but it isn't going to happen quickly.

And since I'm generally in the mode of speaking with business people who have a tiny amount of time, like it's just not worth it for us to start there. But I do believe that there is this other, this other layer of belief that is where more of us connect and kind of cycling back to some of what we were talking about in the beginning.

I think that there that's where you start to get people excited about things when you can make a case or you can get someone to see that, oh, actually, as much as I have with my army rangers, that there's way more that we have in common then, then we don't. And I don't say that from a Pollyanna standpoint.

I actually say that very, you know, from a tactical standpoint that I think we convince ourselves that we just can't make the case with this person. This person's just not going to change. And I'm like, well, based on the argument they're hearing, no, they're not. You know, and there just may ultimately be that as you say, sometimes they're not going to want to.

Okay. But I would say with a company where someone's just trying to, you know, he doesn't believe in the inherent worthiness of han potential. I would still say, yeah, that is an opportunity for you to Jack Russell it. In my mind, what the way that I picture is like, I just, I'm actually going to start to mine in a different place.

Right. So, all right. So the human potential angle isn't going to work, but how can I tie fulfilled human potential to something that person cares about? 

Clare Kumar: The ability to drive revenue and employee. Correct. Right. Exactly. 

Tamsen Webster: Exactly.

Yeah. So it's, it's, And, and again, I will repeat that I think that that is on the responsibility for building those bridges of belief is on you, the person asking for change. So it's your job to figure out how to start from where you like, figure out where, from where they ever, they are. What is the, what are the series of steps that would ever get them to you based on what they value and what they believe to be true. 

and that's going to be even stronger, obviously, if these are things that you believe to be true, because otherwise, I mean, we just, we can't even hide our ability. Yeah. Yeah. I've just found this to be, you know, the more that I've been, you know, not just these principles because these principles have been in play in my, in my, my life and my work for a very long time now, but the particular practice of forming these cases and finding these principles has really just been something I've been working on for the last two years or so.

And Yeah. It's incredibly validating and uplifting work. And not just to me, it's just to other people. Because I mean, I can even see, you know, some of my startup clients are like, oh my gosh, like, you know, whereas they had been talking about their products and walking in and saying, we decarbonize legacy buildings, which might work with some people, like now they can talk to, you know, the building owners that were their actual clients and say, we can help you kind of reduce your building heating costs by controlling the release of stored heat that are coming off your radiators. And they're like-

Clare Kumar: Wait, I care about that. 

Tamsen Webster: I understand that. I care about that part. It's something that I want. It's a solution I haven't heard of. And you're telling me I don't have to pull out my whole furnace and my, my boiler system.

But you're solving the problem that I know I have, which is that the radiators either given out too much heat or not enough. And so that's the shift. And it's really interesting. Sometimes that we, well, you know, two things can happen. It's not always awesome in the beginning, because sometimes people go, Oh, actually, we don't actually have a differentiated idea, or we don't actually have a solid case on which to base this.

And it's really interesting to see that happen. But that has happened actually far, far less than I'm very glad that that happens not very often. Much more often someone starts to go, yeah, that's why I, that's how I, that I see this differently. That's what it is because so much of the time we're forced to like, look at these outside things as the things that are different.

Right. You know, and I, I. you know, whether it's the benefits or, you know, or it's features. And I know I talk about benefit bombing in the book, but, you know, it's it's sister is feature flooding, which is just like, well, we've got this and it comes in pink and, you know, and it's just like that actually isn't it.

Right. Because it doesn't matter what color it is, that they don't actually want to understand it, want it, agree with the approach, any of that. So it's really interesting. I mean, it is about, you know, You know, I'm trying to find ways to talk about this that don't scare people off, given the nature of what I do, but in a lot of ways, it's about our, it's about philosophizing.

It's about articulating your philosophy. It's about articulating your core argument for this change. And when you are talking about your approach, let's say to working with companies, or you're talking about the approach that's embodied in a product. You really, I mean, in one way or another, you are asked for that argument on a regular basis.

You're asked for that, I mean, truly existential argent. Can you argue for why this should, this exists in the first place? Sorry, my dog's shaking off and, you know, I think that, you know, You know, it's, again, it was just, you know, when I had this realization about, about two years ago, I was like, and it was started because, you know, I could see people articulating things beautifully and story structure, or even as a story and whether they're using my red thread structure or something else like story brand, I could still see times when something was articulated as a story and it still didn't work it like it still wasn't effective.

And, and I just got curious about that and I'm like, well, Well, why not? And then I was like, ah, because, right, there is this saying that a story is an arguent. And I had already had a number of people say, yeah, of course, like, , you know, it's most obvious in something like, Aesop's fables, right? Well, this, the actions of the story are arguing for.

Yeah. What Aesop put in the moral of the story, right? That, you know, that slow and steady wins the race, or whatever it might be. But every story of transformation is actually an argent for or against the ways to get there. Like, to how that transformation happened.

And yet, again, it doesn't always work. Like, you know, you and I may say, Well, I don't, I don't like that movie. I don't agree. That's not the lesson I took from it. Okay, why? And then I realized that we kind of just stopped at saying it was an argument. We stopped looking at what is, what creates an argument, not just what creates a story, but what creates an argument in the first place.

And that's where this idea of principles, beliefs came into play because a true argument where this plus this equals that and that this and this are those principles and beliefs and that that is the change is the realization is the is the conclusion that comes from it. All of a sudden I realized, oh my gosh, nobody is talking about what's underneath the story.

And if we really want people to You know, believe enough in our change or our offerings or our products to act on it. Doesn't matter how interesting they are. It doesn't even matter if they understand them. If fundamentally they would never agree with them because they're not answering a question that they have.

They're not based on that approach is not based on things that they believe to be true. We'll never get it. And so this book is very much a process of like just go all the way down to that kind of bedrock layer of saying what are what is that belief based principle based argent for why you're doing this.

Clare Kumar: Yeah, this is bringing to light. Customer conversation I'm having right now about a goal around employee retention and wanting, you know, to run a leadership day and they want to start off with a retention presentation and then get into some wellbeing and then get into some productivity. Like, I'm kind of thinking it's the wrong order because we have to believe and agree on the principles around what drives good performance.

Before we say, how is that going to affect how we're going to hold on to people, if we, if we don't combine these things, we're not going to get to an outcome that people will believe in. And the point I made, I was being rather bold, , people will not stand for, they won't stand for lip service anymore.

So you have to, you have to, you have to do the work and really be clear on what you're trying to do and really be clear on how honest you are being with yourself. 

Tamsen Webster: Yes, absolutely. Because yeah, I said, I said it the other day to someone, it was very funny. She, she was like, well, I was actually just, she and I were talking about change and all this, and she was like, well, yeah, people are pushing back so, you know, we've got to do something different now or something like that. And I was like, yeah, we, people, people are not going back in the box. So, you know, business is now having to deal with. People as people because they're not willing to go back into the machine. So that means that there's this whole body of knowledge of skills that we need to have.

And it's why I'm so passionate about teaching persuasive message design and why we, that it needs a field of practice. This needs to be a whole thing that we know how to do and that we are teaching people to do. Because we don't have a choice. Like you're not going to like prop up AI and be like convinced this person, right?

Like that's not how it's going to happen. And so, but it was funny. She was actually just on a plane and she was literally talking about how the plane was getting pushed back. But here I was like this very philosophical thing. And she was like, well, actually we were just pushing back from the gate. And I'm like, well, I'm still agree with what I said.

I still stand behind it. It was very funny. But I, yeah, I mean, As you say, you and I are very much aligned on the fact that You know, at least on the fact that there are value, there's value in people, there's value in whatever they, it is that they have to bring to the table in whatever manner they bring to it.

, not everyone agrees with that. I know that. , but. Again, I, you know, back to one of your earlier questions, I cannot waste time or effort or moments thinking about those people when there are people who do share this belief that you and I have and, and, and, and the, And that problem is fixable for them, right?

And so that was so much about why I was truly driven to write this book, because it was just like, I can't change, I can't change minds who don't, who aren't looking for that or who aren't yet at a level of awareness that makes them curious.

Clare Kumar: I say I want, I want to find people whose ears to the ground already. Yeah. I mean, for a solution here. Yeah. 

Tamsen Webster: Yeah, exactly. And again, it's not that, you know, I'm not willing to be out there and doing, and, and, you know, doing my part to start, you know, creating education around this. Cause I know as well as you do that you start to put out other ways to approach and then people end up just being curious about like, well, whoa, what is that in the first place?

Oh my goodness. Kitty. And, and so great. But, you know, again, it's like, fundamentally, you know, as I say on my website, I'm focused on people who are focused on change, which in my mind is not just one time action, it's sustained action. And. Once you switch and or once you decide that that is the thing that you're pursuing the true change transformational change.

It brings in a whole other set of considerations that I think generally we skip over that are unaddressed. Yeah, not intentionally. It's just, again, I, you know, it's a lot of, it's just a product of, you know, a lot of communication information. A lot of persuasion and influence was based on management structure and thinking that was back to the factory model and back to, you know, line, line and staff and, and command and control.

A lot of the persuasion and influence advice  acknowledges that. But when you look at other fields, psychology, learning, which is where I'm right now, adult learning, particularly, where people bring their own experiences to this, they have their own pre-existing frames of reference about things, you know, you can't And as we're talking about this, you know, generationally, people aren't willing to go into the box, you know, and then once we got out of the box with the pandemic, even, you know, the older generations are like, oh, heck no, I'm not going back.

Clare Kumar:Yeah, the whole, the whole, big takeaway from last night's convention was we're not going back. And I think that's exactly the, that's exactly the sentiment for the way we work and, You know, a lot of political issues as well. 

Tamsen Webster: And so the good news is, is that a lot of the things that we need, right? I mean, I exist in these other fields and that's, you know, very much what I've always seen myself as playing a role in.

I mean, I say I'm an English to English translator. That's, that's my job. You know, the most general way is oftentimes it's from expert to every day. But sometimes it's from one field into the, the other into the other. Just as a quick example, I mean, I was doing some reading for class and, you know, it's about adult education and, you know, a lot of people don't even think about adult education or if they think about it, they think of it as like continuing-ed or, you know, CPE credits and things like that.

If you think about adult education as I do in the context of it's, you know, helping and understanding how adults learn something new, period, right? Then you start to see how critically important it is that it's, that we have some of those, that knowledge and skills because any innovation, any new product, new offering, new idea, they're by definition is going to have a bit of an educational component to it because There's something new about it.

And if we don't understand what's required as by the way, psychologists understand, as neuroscience understand, as cognitive behaviorists understand, as adult learning folks understand, adult educators understand what is required for someone to understand and adopt new information, we are missing out on so much of the opportunity of these amazing ideas, these amazing products, approaches, et cetera, that we're developing.

And so, you know, adult educators are so interesting to me. They, they, you know, they, they describe, you know, adult educations and adult educators see themselves as change agents because of that, because they're all about transforming frames of reference. You know, when I read that for the first time, I was like, gosh, it's just so backwards to me that, that business, which is constantly looking for change agents, doesn't understand that one of the primary roles of a change agent is in fact, adult education. Helping people understand and adopt new ideas.

Fundamentally, you know, these principles that are in this book are just about that. Like, what are the principles behind helping your fellow han understand and adopt and truly adopt something new so that, you know, yes, transformational change, but just so that something different can happen, whatever that might be.

Clare Kumar: You're making me think of Don Norman. I don't know. Don Norman. Don Norman has written a book, the Design of Everyday Things, which has been Oh cool. I think I got it. 10 years. Take notes. I think I got it 10 years ago, and that was the 25th edition. So Nice. Okay. It's, it's a freaking classic. And he studied psychology and engineering, so it was understanding design.

As you are doing looking at how do we work as hans and, and my degree with biology, I care about the physiology, psychology, like we're animals. We work certain ways. And now you want us to work this way and it doesn't suit our hunan nature. So. No, it's like, yeah. So I love this cross pollination of ideas.

Yeah. So speaking of biology, a book recommended to me by, you know, one of my professors, Victoria Marsik, Dr. Victoria Marsik, who is essentially like the founder of organizational learning. Like she essentially created organizational and incidental learning. Incidents of learning, particularly as a field, as she was like, Oh, yeah, there's this great book.

It's from the mid 2000s, I think, called the Web of Life by I'm going to mispronounce the name, but Fritjof Capra, C A P R A, , who is a, he's a physicist and he's talking about very much the, , yeah, the kind of ecosystem nature of things and how, you know, essentially, and I know this from working with some of my TEDx New England speakers who are all STEM focused, who talk about how, you know, there is fundamentally, You know, the earth, what we think of as a separate planet from us and who we are is made of the same matter as we are, it's just we're all in a different form.

And so, you know, once you have that realization, you're like, Oh, this starts to switch things. So again, it just comes back to my stance earlier that the more the The more perspectives you take or the more perspectives you try on, the better you can potentially see things, or at least the more connections you start to get.

And that is Hazel telling me that it's getting time. 

Clare Kumar: Mom, wrap it up, wrap it up. So for those who are just listening to the audio, you will have probably heard an interruption from Elliot who was on my desk and his tail kept waving by. And this is Hazel, who's a gorgeous whippet, is it? She's a greyhound.

Greyhound. Greyhound. Yeah. Greyhound. And you have Walnut as well. I do. Walnut doesn't bark like she does. Yeah. Oh, all right. So, well, that's a clear signal. I'm going to respect Hazel's wishes there. And I want to thank you for joining me. My pleasure. It's a, it's an incredible body of work and it's going to have profound impact.

I urge everyone to pick up a copy of Say What You Can't Unhear and Finding the Red Thread because Tamsen, you may not know this, but anytime I'm creating content that I think I want to be compelling to get my point of view across. I start with that first step, which is find your shared values, which is, which is in this work as well.

Right. So it's your, your gifts are, are big to this. Oh, thank you, Clare. Yeah. 

Tamsen Webster: Yeah. Thanks. This is such a pleasure. Thank you. Thank you for giving me the opportunity to chat about these things that I love so much. 

Clare Kumar: Amazing. Anytime.

 

Book a discovery call with Clare? Click here to contact me.

Footer

Clare Kumar helps organizations create “neurological safety” so more people can live, work, learn, and play with ease.

Proudly autistic with a side order of ADHD, Clare’s lived experience and work with many neurodivergent clients as a productivity coach for two decades compels to respect that #ProductivityIsPersonal.

If we want the best from customers and employees alike, it’s time to create more hospitable containers protecting the most sensitive. Discuss collaborating with Clare.

From the Blog

Would you be okay with a 3am meeting?

What is “Neurological Safety” and why do we need it?

DEIA is not dead – Inspiration from the SHRM Inclusion Conference

Useful Links

  • About
  • Media
  • Praise
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
International Coach Federation Canadian Association of Professional Speakers National Association of Productivity & Organization Professionals Professional Organizers in Canada
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Substack
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Copyright © 2026 Streamlife Ltd. · All Rights Reserved · Website designed by PibworthPS